Shows Like All Her Fault
Keep the thrills and mysteries going with more twisty TV picks streaming on Peacock.
Key Takeaways
- Peacock offers several mystery and thriller series similar to All Her Fault, featuring intense drama, family secrets, crime investigations, and unexpected twists.
- Recommended titles include Long Bright River, Apples Never Fall, Poker Face, and The Day of the Jackal, each blending suspense with distinctive characters and high-stakes storytelling.
- The lineup spans multiple subgenres, from crime procedurals like Law & Order: Organized Crime and Found to psychological and true-crime-inspired dramas like M.I.A. and A Friend of the Family
Peacock's All Her Fault, a suburban thriller with an intriguing mystery, remains one of the most absorbing limited series dramas in recent years. It's so good, that once you're done with it, you're going to want more shows like All Her Fault.
The Peacock Original series was adapted from the book of the same name by Andrea Mara, and stars Sarah Snook, Jake Lacy, Dakota Fanning, and Michael Peña. Nominated for Golden Globe Awards and a Television Critics Association Award, All Her Fault is perfect for bingeing, and once you finish it, it's the kind of series that makes you desperate to watch something similar, just to keep up the endorphin high. Luckily, the Peacock library is full of amazing shows like All Her Fault.
Check out our list below of of shows similar to All Her Fault that you can watch on Peacock, all filled with twists, turns, mysteries, and thrills.
RELATED: Best Shows to Binge in One Weekend on Peacock
Shows like All Her Fault now streaming on Peacock
M.I.A.
This Peacock Original crime drama series sees Etta Tiger Jonze (Shannon Gisela) bearing witness to violence firsthand as her family falls victim to a drug cartel run by Rojas family. After the life-changing event, Etta sets out on a dangerous journey from the Florida Keys through Miami’s neon-lit underbelly that will define who she is and what she’s ultimately capable of.
Stream M.I.A.
Long Bright River
This Peacock Original series, based on the 2020 book by Liz Moore, stars Amanda Seyfried as a Philadelphia cop investigating a series of murders that she begins to suspect may connect to her personal history. Long Bright River features the dramatic twists and relatable heart that made All Her Fault such a satisfying watch. (Read our spoiler-filled breakdown of every twist and turn from Long Bright River.)
Stream Long Bright River.
Apples Never Fall
Starring Annette Bening, Sam Neill, Alison Brie, and All Her Fault’s Jake Lacy, Apples Never Fall follows the Delaney family, who are caught in the throes of a mystery when Joy (Bening) disappears and her husband, Stan (Neill), becomes a suspect. The Peacock Original limited series, based on the book by Liane Moriarty, is a dramatic mystery rooted in family secrets.
Stream Apples Never Fall.
Poker Face
A mystery-of-the-week comedy-drama from Rian Johnson and starring Natasha Lyonne alongside a deep roster of celebrity guest stars, Poker Face revolves around Charlie Cale (Lyonne), a woman on the run who has an extraordinary ability to determine when someone is lying. Working odd jobs and drifting across the country while trying to fly under the radar, Charlie encounters zany characters and solves mysterious murders no matter where she goes.
Stream Poker Face.
RELATED: Poker Face Producer Says Season 2 Pushes the Show to New Heights
Law & Order: Organized Crime
A spinoff of NBC’s long-running cop procedural Law & Order: SVU, Law & Order: Organized Crime puts the spotlight on Christopher Meloni returning as NYPD detective Elliot Stabler. He and his team investigate crime syndicates while rebuilding his life after a personal tragedy.
Stream Law & Order: Organized Crime.
The Day of the Jackal
Eddie Redmayne plays the elusive world-class assassin known as The Jackal, chased across Europe by Lashana Lynch's tenacious British intelligence officer. The Peacock Original is a high-stakes thrill ride full of daring action, disguises, and suspense.
Stream The Day of the Jackal.
The ‘Burbs
A contemporary reimagining of Joe Dante's 1989 cult movie of the same name, this mystery series stars Keke Palmer as Samira, a new mother, just a year into her marriage with Rob (Jack Whitehall). They've exited their life in the city to get through the early days of parenthood at Rob's family home in the idyllic neighborhood of Hinkley Hills. As is the case with most small towns, there's a lot of weirdness simmering in the cul-de-sac, and it launches former lawyer Samira into investigation mode.
Stream The ‘Burbs.
RELATED: The 'Burbs Creative Team on Season 1 Ending & Hopes for Season 2
Found
NBC’s hit procedural drama Found stars Shanola Hampton as a recovery specialist who will stop at nothing to solve missing person cases that have been overlooked by the system. The twist: She has a major secret hidden in her basement that could jeopardize everything
Stream Found.
A Friend of the Family
A Friend of the Family tells the story of the Broberg family, who face tragedy in the 1970s when their daughter Jan is kidnapped multiple times by a seemingly trustworthy family friend. Based on a true story and produced by Jan Broberg and her mother Mary Ann, the critically acclaimed and dramatic limited series is a harrowing story told with detail and care. The series stars Anna Paquin, Colin Hanks, and Jake Lacy (in his first of three Peacock Original roles).
Stream A Friend of the Family.
Content availability subject to change.
